Edinburgh Fringe 2024 Reviews – When Vincent Met John, Crime and Punishment, Michael Porter: Love and Brain Damage, Galahad Takes a Bath, 1 Moment in Time, and I Did Something I Shouldn’t Have

When Vincent Met John, TheSpace at Niddry Street.

4-stars

An imaginary meeting between Vincent van Gogh and John Lennon, when both are at a crisis point in their lives and careers, leads to a fascinating debate about the nature, value and definition of art. Lennon, of course, has the advantage of knowing who van Gogh is (or was) but van Gogh, obviously ignorant of Lennon, cannot comprehend how someone like him could have what might be considered to be artistic ability. Today, we would consider both to be among the finest exponents of their art in their own time; but is one better than the other, or do different eras simply favour different styles? Can one person influence another and help them to see a useful way forward, or are they condemned to continue, blinkered, along their own, private path? Murray Andrews and Nick Wilkes deliver intense, convincing performances – they are exactly how we remember Lennon and imagine how van Gogh would sound and behave; and Mr Wilkes’ eloquent text is crammed with thoughtful and thought-provoking ideas and observations that make you continue to think about it long after it’s over.

Crime and Punishment, TheSpace on The Mile.
4-stars

Talking Shadows bring their adaptation of Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment as a smartly condensed 45-minute play, featuring a talented ensemble of young actors. The tormented Raskolnikov stalks the stage while the rest of the cast ominously sit side by side at the back of the stage, watching, waiting, and reciting in unison (which they perform with chilling accuracy), providing voices in Raskolnikov’s head and adding to his nightmare. The relatively large cast adapt to the small acting space, without compromising on the fluidity and foreboding of their movement. A gripping retelling of this dark story with some excellent performances!

Michael Porter: Love and Brain Damage, Just the Tonic Nucleus.

4-stars

Michael Porter’s new show, Love and Brain Damage, gets its unusual name from an unusual event in Michael’s own childhood. As a boy, a freak car accident left him with a frontal lobe brain injury which actually caused him to die three times before miraculously being nursed back to life over six weeks. Unsurprisingly, this has had a profound effect on him; on his voice, on his emotions, on his ability to communicate, and on his confidence. His comic delivery has an unrestrained, powerful quality, full of attack, and combined with his (self-confessed) aggressive Northern Ireland accent, let’s just say that nobody sleeps when Michael Porter is talking! Much of this show is about how that incident has affected him, but there’s also loads of great material about relocating to Scotland, his tough upbringing, and the joys of living in a town called… err… Muff. Full of energy and sincerity, the innate kindness and vulnerability that lurks under his gruff exterior shines through and makes for a rewarding, educational and, indeed, very funny hour.

Galahad Takes a Bath, Zoo Southside.

From Thomas Malory, through Alfred, Lord Tennyson to Lerner and Loewe and Monty Python, the Court of King Arthur has inspired literature, music and humour. The latest take on Camelot is Juggler’s Mistake’s Galahad Takes a Bath, starring Forest Malley as the eponymous knight, fresh in from a day’s knighting, and in desperate need of a bath – after all, it’s vital to maintain the clean purity that’s his brand – but first, he’ll take some questions, press conference style. Yes, he has a slightly unorthodox relationship with Lancelot, and no, he can’t give any further updates on the progress to find the Grail, other than what’s already been officially released. But when you dig down into Galahad the man, can anyone truly be that pure and untainted? Written with punchy spark by Jojo Jones, the play’s honesty and sincerity paint a picture of a wonderfully modern and recognisable Galahad, both brilliantly funny and surprisingly tragic. A hilarious, unpredictable, epoch-bending show, with a superb performance by Forest Malley, who invests Galahad with an unexpected, but completely believable personality. One of the best performances in this year’s Fringe.

1 Moment in Time, TheSpace at Surgeons’ Hall.

Sean Alexander, the Confusionist, asks us to consider one moment in time, and it’s a theme he weaves into the whole hour, including some truly extraordinary tricks and feats. Without giving any games away, there’s a trick that involves us all doing an elaborate sum on the calculators on our phones that has an amazing end result; there are other amazing tricks that involve a wedding ring and a message in a balloon, and my favourite, a deceptively simple trick which involves the synchronicity of two packs of cards shuffled separately. Mr Alexander presents the show with warmth, heart, and a sensitivity for the emotions that the show releases, and you’ll come away from it with a sense of awe and bafflement. Astounding!

I Did Something I Shouldn’t Have, TheSpace on The Mile.

3-stars

Family secrets, eh? Every family has them; most don’t let them get quite this out of hand. Estranged from their father, and with their mother dead, three brothers grow up together as best they can under the care of the oldest, Harrison. Middle brother Will suffers badly from the effects of being abused by his father; and youngest brother Sean wants to know more about this father that no one ever talks about. After all, he’s sixteen now, and needs to understand his own identity. Vince, the father, is a complete monster of a man, and they’re all better off without him. But when Sean’s curiosity gets the better of him, he starts a chain of events that they would all come to regret. Paul-James Green’s ambitious play tells a fascinating and engrossing story that keeps the audience locked in and engaged throughout, although, to be fair, there are a couple of aspects to the plot that lack credibility. There’s a particularly strong performance by Gary Simpson as Vince – a genuinely threatening and evil presence on stage, and there is also some extremely impressive stage combat – especially involving Mr Simpson and Richard Michell as Will. If you’re looking for a happy ending – look no further! It’s not exactly a pleasant play, but it does expose a few family home truths.

The Edinburgh Fringe All Month Long – 19th August 2024

What’s in store for us in Edinburgh today?

Here’s the schedule for August 19th.

9:50 – When Vincent Met John, theSpace @ Niddry St. From the Edinburgh Fringe website:

“Vincent died in 1890, John died in 1980, both of gunshot wounds to the chest. But imagine what might have happened had the two greatest artists of their time met? Five years before their deaths, both men went through profound change. Van Gogh renounced religious ambition, began to paint, and, despite arguments with antagonist Paul Gaugin, created his life’s masterworks. Lennon renounced sex, drugs and rock’n’roll, began five years seclusion and, despite arguments with antagonist Paul McCartney, created a son and his last album. This play takes place at their exact moment of crisis and decision.”

An early start for a play that confronts us with a fascinating comparison – Van Gogh v. Lennon. I’ve no idea where it’s going to take us, but I’m fascinated to find out.

11:35 – Crime and Punishment, theSpace on the Mile.

“In the sweltering heat of a Saint Petersburg summer, impoverished student Raskolnikov wrestles with the thoughts of the good he could do were he able to lay hands on the wealth of an unscrupulous old woman. Dostoyevsky’s seminal masterpiece of psychological torment sees Raskolnikov unravel as his guilt and conscience collide with the reality of his murderous dreams. Praise for writer/director Rebecca Vines’ previous works: ‘Chilling… brilliant… powerful’ ***** (BroadwayBaby.com). ‘A cut above’ **** (TheWeeReview.co.uk). ‘Power and strength’ **** (BritishTheatreGuide.info).”

Somehow I managed to read Crime and Punishment when I was 17 and I have absolutely no idea how I managed it because I certainly couldn’t now. But I love the idea of squeezing Raskolnikov’s story into forty minutes, and if this is done well it could be brilliant.

13:50 – Michael Porter – Love and Brain Damage, Just the Tonic Nucleus.

“Michael sheds light on the everyday challenges of his condition, from the struggles of memory loss and impulse control to the comical mishaps that ensue when navigating social interactions. Whether it’s forgetting where he parked his car (he doesn’t drive) or unintentionally blurting out inappropriate remarks, Michael’s adventures are sure to leave audiences in stitches. From finding himself on the wrong path surrounded by the wrong people, to facing the harsh realities of death and prison, Michael’s journey is one of resilience, growth, strength and, ultimately, love.”

For a comedy show, this sounds like it could be quite a challenging experience. I’m looking forward to hearing Michael talk about his life and adventures.

16:00 – Galahad Takes a Bath, Zoo Southside.

“’I got very little, little to no media training, so… Sorry!’ Sir Galahad the Pure, Knight of the Round Table, son of Lancelot the Brave, is taking a bath. Even the chosen one needs a break sometimes, okay? But long soaks in the bath can lead to painful questions, and the cleaner Galahad gets, the dirtier he becomes. In this darkly comedic show about sex, jobs, and the Holy Grail, by the time Galahad gets out, he might not want to be so Pure anymore.”

This sounds like a delightfully ridiculous set-up. It was the pure nonsense of it that appealed. I’m expecting Galahad to use the hour as a free therapy session. Let’s see how it turns out!

18:00 – 1 Moment in Time, theSpace @ Surgeons’ Hall.

“In his brand new, thought-provoking show, magician and mind illusionist Sean Alexander reflects on the defining moments in time that shape each and every one of us. With jaw dropping magic throughout, each instance intertwined with powerful metaphors and storytelling, this show is unlike anything else. Discover your moments in time all over again… ‘You are incredible, I will have you attend the palace’ (HRH Princess Michael of Kent). ‘Incredibly talented’ (Stephen Mulhern). ‘I love magic that tells a story and I really like you’ (Simon Cowell).”

I’ve seen a little of Sean Alexander’s work online and it looks very impressive, so I’m hoping for a breathtaking fifty minutes of amazement.

20:15 – I Did Something I Shouldn’t Have…, theSpace on the Mile.

“16 year-old Sean Parker has never known his Dad and wants to change that. His brothers are unenthusiastic about his plans… Undeterred and egged on by his best friend, Sean successfully makes contact with and meets with his Dad… but at what cost? This reunion carries risks and potential danger that may affect all their lives resulting in them never being the same again…”

Those moments in one’s life when one makes a big decision – there’s no going back after it. That’s what I’m expecting here, a strong and powerful examination of the reunion to end all reunions.

Check back later to see how we enjoyed all these shows!