Edinburgh Fringe 2023 Reviews – Those Who Can’t Do, Santi and Naz, Stark Bollock Naked, The Quality of Mercy: Concerning the Life and Crimes of Dr Harold Shipman, and Andrew Frank: Ecstatic Blasphemy

Those Who Can’t Do, Laughing Horse @ The Brass Monkey.

Balancing a life as a responsible teacher on the one hand, and a party larrikin on the other is a tricky business, as Ty Gray’s very funny Those Who Can’t Do shows. Making sure the kids don’t see your social media, trying to avoid being caught out hungover, and avoiding visits from your partygoing mother are all vital personal goals! Ty is a very likeable guy and has some excellent material with some great punchlines. In Saturday’s show he had a very awkward moment when he dropped his glass of water and it smashed everywhere, causing the show to be suspended for a good five minutes; but he used the hiatus as a strength and came back fighting – which a less confident performer would have found a struggle. A strong performer and a funny show!

3-stars

Santi and Naz, Pleasance Courtyard.

The partition of India is a frequent inspiration for drama; and in Santi and Naz it is used as the backdrop for the tale of two best friends. To what extent will they be separated by religion, partition and sexuality? Santi was always fascinated by books and wanting to know more about the world – even though she always expected to spend her life in the village and working with the sugar cane. Naz had no interest in reading; all she wanted was to be Santi’s best friend. But as the two grow older into adulthood, and an arranged marriage is on the cards, what does the future hold for both of them? Rose-Marie Christian and Karendip Phull play Santi and Naz with great conviction and affection, and the text has some beautiful passages of lyrical writing. But it is too long; too much time is spent establishing the girls’ childhood friendship, and the issue of Naz’s sexuality is only lightly touched upon. Enjoyable performances, but it could all be a little tighter and pack a greater punch.

3-stars

Stark Bollock Naked, Assembly Roxy.

Two very engaging performers deliver an innovative and imaginative show about that age old issue of the female body’s ticking clock and the right of the woman to choose her own destiny. The first part of the show involves video and imagery projection on one of their (naked) bodies and is funny, telling and very clever. The second part loses impact as the two performers become the woman’s brain – it took me a long time to realise they were her brain; I thought the unusual headgear suggested her intestines, which made no sense at all. There’s also a very silly song that potentially trivialises the importance of its earlier message – although maybe that was its intent.

A very good idea for a show that starts strongly and then disintegrates as it progresses.

The Quality of Mercy: Concerning the Life and Crimes of Dr Harold Frederick Shipman, The Space @ Surgeon’s Hall.

Shipman is in his prison cell, reciting his thoughts into a tape recorder to set the record straight – he doesn’t want to be associated with that louse Ian Brady, after all. His first thoughts are to his mother, who died of cancer at the age of 43, and who suffered terribly from the illness. If only he could have shortened her suffering by bringing her life to an end earlier? This gives him the justification for committing the unspeakable series of murders for which he was responsible, hiding behind the facade of benevolent euthanasia. As his crimes increase, the names of his victims appear on a projected backdrop; eventually you are mesmerised by the sheer numbers involved. Edwin Flay’s magnificent writing allows Shipman’s true motivations to seep out, despite whatever the wretched man may pretend; and his performance as the vain, megalomaniac arbiter of life or death stands out as one of the best I’ve seen for a very long time.

Andrew Frank: Ecstatic Blasphemy, Hill Street Theatre.

Andrew Frank was educated – for want of a better word – at a school – if you can call it that – subjugated within a Christian Fundamentalist church, adjacent to a highway in Arkansas, where their father was the pastor. And if that isn’t a recipe for a disastrous childhood, they don’t know what is. Ecstatic Blasphemy is a hilarious hour revisiting their upbringing, family life, and all the little repressions and – let’s be honest – lies that blighted their childhood. With a mass of very funny material constantly on hand, Andrew is a naturally very funny and ebullient performer whose main purpose on stage is to show the ridiculousness of strict religious adherence, which they do with charm, personality and a huge amount of laughs. Terrific stuff.

4-stars

The Edinburgh Fringe All Month Long – 12th August 2023

Have I got a list of shows for today? I sure do!

Here’s the schedule for 12th August:

11.30 – Those Who Can’t Do, Laughing Horse @ The Brass Monkey. From the Edinburgh Fringe website:

“Ty juggles a double life between being a respectable teacher during the week, and a fun-loving party animal on the weekend. Hiding this from the students is hard. Anecdotes and jokes from Ty’s first few years as a teacher, and the lengths he must go to so that he can hide his personal life antics and budding comedy career from his students.”

Teacher turned stand up is not an uncommon career change! Look forward to seeing it.

13.30 – Santi and Naz, Pleasance Courtyard.

“Best friends Santi and Naz live in pre-partition India. One Sikh, one Muslim, they have little understanding of how religion will divide them. As the political situation in their country worsens and the threat of separation looms large on the horizon, they decide to take drastic action. Award-winning company The Thelmas explore queer love, identity and loyalty, set against the backdrop of a country soon to be changed forever. Winner of the Pleasance’s Charlie Hartill Fund. Praise for Ladykiller (2018): ‘A smash hit’ ***** (BroadwayBaby.com). ‘Superb’ **** (Scotsman).”

As a lover of India, and fascinated by its recent history, I’m sure this will provide a fascinating perspective.

15.10 – Stark Bollock Naked, Assembly Roxy.

“Is the motherhood question bugging you too? An international smash hit about our reproductive shelflife and what (not) to do with those (ageing) eggs. Featuring stunning video mapping, comedy-infused storytelling and a live score of gynaecological instruments, stark bollock naked is a multimedia show with a real naked body and an honest conversation about reproduction, abortion and the biological clock. Game Ovar-ies. ‘Winningly hilarious and visually enthralling’ (FringeBiscuit.co.uk). ‘A satirical homage to eggs. Perfect comic timing’ (Luxembourg Times). VAULT Festival Pick of the Week (Lyn Gardner).”

A title like that doesn’t offer much of a hiding place, but it sounds like it’s going to make lots of serious points. We shall see!

17:35 – The Quality of Mercy: Concerning the Life and Crimes of Dr Harold Frederick Shipman, The Space @ Surgeon’s Hall.

“From his cell in the early hours of the morning, Dr Harold Shipman records a confessional tape as he prepares to end his life. Patiently fashioning a crude noose, he reflects on the choices, compulsions and fascinations that cemented his place as the most prolific serial killer in British history. Exhaustively researched, this multiple award-nominated drama interrogates society’s attitudes towards death, justice and compassion, and is written and performed by Edwin Flay, the grandson of Shipman victim Renee Lacey.”

This is one of those shows that only the Edinburgh Fringe can throw up every so often. The fact that it is performed by a relative of one of Shipman’s victims only adds to the closeness and intimacy of the experience. I expect this to be very hard-hitting indeed.

19.30 – Andrew Frank: Ecstatic Blasphemy, Hill Street Theatre.

“Named one of the Best Undiscovered Comedians in America by Thrillist Magazine, Seattle comedian Andrew Frank delivers a hilarious set about growing up as a pastor’s kid, finding queer joy beyond fundamentalist Christianity, and performing subversive stand-up for more than a decade in America’s Bible Belt. In an hour of rapid-fire jokes, Frank takes aim at the constructs and symbols of evangelical Christianity, re-contextualizing them through the lens of empathy, creativity, and scepticism. Provocative and fiercely vulnerable, Frank creates moments of collective healing and euphoria through the liberating power of laughter.”

I’ve not heard of Andrew Frank before – but he sounds a complete hoot!

Check back later to see how we enjoyed all these shows!