Edinburgh Fringe 2024 Reviews – Nina Rose Carlin: Seeking Representation, The Grim, With All My Fondest Love, and The Dreamer – Live

Nina Rose Carlin: Seeking Representation, TheSpace at Surgeons’ Hall.

3-stars

Nina Rose Carlin seeks the path to Hollywood stardom by following a list of six simple rules guaranteed to see you make it big in Tinseltown; unfortunately, none of them seem to work. From not knowing which Los Angeles airport to land in, to selling her soul to an AI version of herself, surely there must be a way for Nina to become a star and avoid the existential dread that (apparently) all actors face! Nina Rose Carlin commands the stage with a blend of Hollywood pizzazz and out-of-place smalltown girl failure, looking every inch a star and with an amazing voice to boot. In fact, the song interludes are the best part of the show; reflective, tuneful, and heartfelt. Some of the humour doesn’t quite land, mainly because of the use of American references that most British audiences simply wouldn’t recognise. I’d love to see her do something more – I reckon she could nail Sondheim.

The Grim, Underbelly Bristo Square.

4-stars

The body of the late Jackie “Guillotine” Gallagher is next on the slab at the undertakers to be measured for his coffin; but this simple task involves a little more of a challenge than those undertakers, Rob and Shaun, were expecting. The “Grim” of the title is an Irish folklore apparition that takes the form of a huge black dog with red glowing eyes; see one, and you’ll be dead before long. Part ghost story, part comedy thriller, this terrific new play by Edmund Morris involves voices, revenge and a bit of blood too. Very well acted on a tiny, odd-shaped stage, it’s full of surprises – just remember to share your sweeties next time.

With All My Fondest Love, Greenside @ George Street.

4-stars

In the attic are boxes and boxes of old love letters, diaries, train tickets, photographs, records, and even cricket trophies; all the detritus of lives gone by. Noah Wild traces the early days of his grandparents’ first meetings, their letters to each other, and their hopes and dreams for a happy future together. Their letters are signed With All My Fondest Love. But relationships don’t always go the way we hope, and every good thing has to end at some point. But not before the birth of Neil, Noah’s father; or else Noah wouldn’t have come into this world! Noah, too, is still suffering from a relationship breakdown, being ghosted by his ex, and drawing parallels between his failed relationship and the gradually disintegrating relationship of his grandparents. None of this will be possible one hundred years on, where love letters are mere texts and train tickets are pdf’s. Elegantly and emotionally written, and full of recognisable Oxford references if you know that city well, Mr Wild delivers a powerful and heartfelt performance filled with all those tiny elements that go to make up the early days of a relationship. It tugs at all your emotions, and reminds us of someone we knew and loved.

The Dreamer – Live, Underbelly’s Circus Hub on the Meadows.

4-stars

No gimmicks, no sideshows; James Phelan starts his Dreamer show off straight away with a couple of extraordinary tricks, that involve predicting cards selected from a pack by different people from the audience, and piecing together various numbers chosen by random audience members to make a potentially very profitable sequence (I’ll say no more). As the show progresses, he involves the whole crowd in an experiment to see how well their imagination works (I’ll tell you now, mine was fairly rotten) and from that, he chooses a few audience members on whom he can practise a very special kind of mind control (again, I’ll say no more). James Phelan’s tricks defy all sense of logic and reason and leave you totally spellbound. I haven’t a clue as to how he did any of it – I just watched, agog, and in awe.

The Edinburgh Fringe All Month Long – 17th August 2024

Only 4 shows today!

Here’s the schedule for August 17th.

11:35 – Nina Rose Carlin: Seeking Representation, theSpace @ Surgeons’ Hall. From the Edinburgh Fringe website:

“She’s an LA actress. Of course she knows her rising moon sign. Of course she can arrange dry-cleaning for a studio executive’s offspring in her sleep. Of course she takes her coffee with a splash of oat milk, and a heaping spoonful of existential dread. With live music, unhinged characters, and a bit of pixie dust (read: Ozempic) Seeking Representation is a one-woman show meets cabaret with a subversive sucker punch. From five-star Hollywood Fringe Festival award-winner and certified LA actress herself, Nina Rose Carlin!”

I confess I know nothing about Nina Rose Carlin but there was something about this description that piqued my curiosity!

13:15 – The Grim, Underbelly, Bristo Square.

“London, 1964. Shaun and Robert are trying to get through another shift as undertakers in the East End, but on the day they’re due to fit deceased murderer, Jackie Gallagher, for his coffin and with strange happenings afoot, all is not as it seems… Following the success of his ‘holler-out-loud funny’ (TheSmuReviews.co.uk) Fringe debut You’re Dead, Mate, award-winning playwright Edmund Morris is back with his latest, darkest comedy: The Grim.”

You’re Dead, Mate was one of the most intriguing and entertaining plays of last year’s Fringe, so I was keen to see what Edmund Morris has come up with for this year! This play sounds like it could have an element of Joe Orton to it – looking forward to finding out.

15:05 – With All My Fondest Love, Greenside @ George Street.

“How well can you know your own family? A grandson discovers the hidden secrets behind his grandparents’ ordinary yet curious marriage. Using real-life letters and diaries, Noah Wild struggles to fill in the blanks in his own family history, from burnt letters to unspoken loss. Struggling with his own heartbreak, he follows love through entwined past generations to reflect on how to live in the present. A true story discovered and retold, this moving new monologue explores how love and grief change across a lifetime. ‘Beautiful… a wonderful piece of theatre’ (WildRoseAndPearls.com).”

I have often wondered how, in this digital age, future generations will be able to look back and discover the secrets of the past; you can’t help but think finding old emails and texts won’t have the same allure. Noah Wild’s personal story sounds fascinating and if this is done well it could be a superb piece of theatre.

17:15 – The Dreamer – Live, Underbelly’s Circus Hub on the Meadows.

“’Magic is in his bones. Disbelief, flabbergasted, stunned’ ***** (Herald). It’s time to believe in magic… Award-winning magician James Phelan, infamous for jamming the BBC switchboard after correctly predicting the lottery, returns with this ground-breaking new magic show. Touching on his parents’ 12 year struggle with IVF, The Dreamer is a celebration of the impossible becoming possible. With magic unparalleled elsewhere at Fringe, this show will leave you aching with laughter and dizzy in disbelief. ‘One to watch in the world of magic’ **** (The List)”

With magic running through his veins – Paul Daniels was his uncle – I’m sure this will be a stunner of a show. Here’s hoping!

Check back later to see how we enjoyed all these shows!