Edinburgh Fringe 2025 Reviews – Mr Jones, It’s Gonna Blow, Elon Musk: Lost in Space, Laura Benanti: Nobody Cares, The Black Hole, and Ali Woods: Basher

Mr Jones, Greenside @ George Street.Next year it will be 60 years since the Aberfan disaster, when a coal tip slip engulfed the village of Aberfan, trapping the village’s children in the school and taking 144 lives including 116 children. I am too young to remember it, but my parents, and all the adults of my childhood memory, would talk of it in hushed, sad tones and grim sadness. Liam Holmes’ brilliant new play, Mr Jones, tells the story of the disaster but from a different angle; that of a survivor coming to terms with the loss of a brother. The play offers us three different ways of dealing with the grief; escaping from the community, retreating into a silent shell, and bravely trying to continue as best one can. Immaculately written, with a genuine feel for the love of a small community, and superbly acted by Mabil Gwynne as Angharad and Liam Holmes himself as Stephen, this stunning play is truly emotional but superbly structured to allow for regular opportunities to reflect and celebrate the humour in everyday life. Mrs Chrisparkle was in tears at the end – and she wasn’t the only one. A must-see highlight of the Fringe. 5 stars.

It’s Gonna Blow, Pleasance Dome.4-starsPompeii, 79 AD. We’re queueing up to get into the citizens’ meeting to air our grievances and seek the Gods’ blessings – or if not the Gods’, then at least the Mayor’s. With rumours flying around that Herculaneum is being destroyed by fire and earthquake, it’s so regrettable that the mayor is a conspiracy theorist and a climate change denier. Still, when you’ve still got a bottle of Vesuvio Noir, there’s always hope. Once again, Fishing4Chips bring a historical event to life with a cast of four playing dozens of quirky characters – and plenty of audience participation too! Extremely funny and delightfully inventive, this farce is performed at breakneck speed, by the brilliant Yasmine Meaden, Elinor Solly, Sean Wareing and Freddie Walker, who set up a terrific rapport with the audience. Tremendous fun. 4 stars.

Elon Musk: Lost in Space, The Space at Surgeons Hall.3-starsEveryone loves Elon Musk, right? Just listen to the cheers of the crowd as he ascends into outer space! He’s on a mission to Mars, accompanied only by his specially programmed super computer robot, who will keep him on course and in touch with Ground Control. Basking in his global superiority, he’s only too happy to keep the President of the United States waiting; after all, Trump’s only in charge of his little part of the world for four years, but Musk – he’s the world leader for evermore! Still, even the best systems aren’t infallible, and sometimes those robots grow just a little too big for their boots… David Morley’s Elon Musk: Lost in Space is a fun concept and has some great lines; at its best, it’s very funny. However, it’s also remarkably weird, with some anachronistic contributions, including from Sir Patrick Moore (a regrettably poor vocal impersonation), who died in 2012, long before Musk became a household name. Ben Whitehead nicely recreates Musk’s boorish behaviour with a very good physical performance, and Sarah Lawrie is excellent as the robot; even so, listening to a robotic voice, no matter how well delivered, does get tedious over the course of an hour. Some good ideas, and some funny passages, but overall, the rocket never quite touches down. 3 stars.

Laura Benanti: Nobody Cares, Underbelly Bristo Square.Is it really bad of me never to have come across the wit and voice of Laura Benanti before? Self-proclaimed one-time Tony award winner, four-time Tony award loser, she brings heaps of personality to her one-woman show, named in honour of her plain-talking older daughter. On her third marriage (this one sounds like a keeper), she has some great stories about making it on Broadway, and how being a people pleaser can take you to places you really shouldn’t go. And don’t mention the perimenopause! With a raft of witty and moving songs, accompanied by her three musicians, Laura brings immense style and sophistication – as well as masses of laughter – to her hour of comedy and music. A perfect comedy cabaret. 5 stars.

The Black Hole, The Space at Venue 45.3-starsAh, those carefree early days of young love, how blissfully enchanting they can be! Two young people, apparently in the early stages of a relationship, are exploring each other’s personalities, as well as their bodies, finding out what each other likes and what they don’t like. They clearly both like whisky – and fortunately, he has brought an extra bottle along. But as the explorations delve deeper, the truth can become hard to take. This is a very intense piece of writing, which could perhaps have benefited from a little more light and shade, but it holds the audience’s attention throughout, and Rosalind Jackson Roe and Vkinn Vats, who also wrote and directed it, give strong, unsettling performances. 3 stars.

Ali Woods: Basher, Underbelly Bristo Square.4-starsAli Woods doesn’t want to boast, but his life is going pretty well at the moment. When you reach the perilous age of 31, and all your friends are getting engaged, there’s a lot of pressure to do the same. This is the sparking point for an hour of terrific comedy reminiscences, including nights on the town with the lads when you’re 18, his strangely intimate relationship with his dad, the sad degeneration of a t-shirt to a pyjama top, and generationally different attitudes to social media. Ali is a lively and energetic figure on stage, with a swift and sure delivery of his meticulously well-planned material. Very likeable and very funny, he quickly gains a confident rapport with the crowd, and his set went down a storm. 4 stars.

Review – Upfront Comedy Slam, Royal and Derngate, Northampton, 23rd October 2022

It’s always a pleasure when John Simmit brings his Upfront Comedy Slam to the Royal and Derngate in Northampton. There’s always a gasp from the audience when he reveals his greatest role (financially at least) was six years in the Teletubbies as the furry green Dipsy. If only Tinky-Winky could see him now. Mr S is a great host, making us all feel very warmly welcome for what turned out to be a brilliant evening of comedy.

Our first act was Athena Kugblenu, whom we’ve seen a couple of times before, and whose act was chiefly built around the theme of working out what class you are. As someone with working class roots, middle class activities and an upper class accent, I’ve genuinely no idea what I am. She works up a great rapport with the audience, including setting up the burly chap in the front row as the butt of absolutely everyone’s jokes throughout the whole night – fortunately he’s obviously an extremely good sport! Very reliable material and delivery that never quite soars, but is always thoroughly entertaining!

Next up, and new to us, was Ali Woods. Here’s a great new find in the Comedy World. Terrific attack, original material, spinning off male mental health in unexpected directions. I loved the idea of Erectile Dysfunction being the name of a Heavy Metal Group. Immensely likeable, and a great range of characterisations for the people he references in his act. We’d really like to see him again.

After the interval came another act who was new to us, Jay Droch. Cutting a smart and dignified appearance, Jay surprised us with a mix of character based comedy and impersonations. The first few minutes of his act he concentrated on the characters in Peaky Blinders, which neither of us has seen, so these comic observations meant nothing to us. When he moved on to his political material, he was absolutely brilliant, with a menacingly ridiculous Boris Johnson, a ludicrously hilarious King Charles and, best of all, a blistering re-imagining of Rishi Sunak as a posh schoolboy skipping to the command of his grisly bullying Indian father. It was absolutely preposterous but utterly brilliant.

Our headline act, and someone we’ve enjoyed many times before, was Kane Brown, who is one of the few comics who has that brilliant ability to riff off whatever vibe the audience presents him. So he spent his entire set with fantastically funny observations about marital relationships, especially as you get older, imagining some of the audience members in the situations he describes. His is one of those acts that just washes over you in a sea of comedy, and it’s very hard to pick out any one sequence of jokes or humour that stands out because it’s all so very funny. We didn’t stop laughing the whole time – a true tonic for the soul.

A terrific night of comedy that flew by. Can’t wait till the next one!