Edinburgh Fringe 2024 Reviews – A Fire Ignites, Malion, The Last Laugh, A Jaffa Cake Musical, To Watch a Man Eat, Sooz Kempner, Colin Hoult: Colin, and The Shadow Boxer

A Fire Ignites, TheSpace at Surgeons’ Hall.

3-stars

It’s impossible for us, in the safety of our free societies in the West, to comprehend the sheer oppression of the Iranian people, specifically the women who dare to protest by burning their hijabs. They face imprisonment at best, execution more likely. Parisa was one such brave young woman who did not survive her protest. Tara Tedjarati writes and performs in her own show, A Fire Ignites, and it’s a vital story that needs to be told to as wide an audience as possible. The characters she portrays represent various aspects of Iranian society, from her best friend Maryam, hiding her sexuality because the truth would be fatal, to Yasaman, Parisa’s mother, who can’t forgive herself for not escaping the post-revolution regime. Fine writing allows us a vital insight into these tragic, yet defiant, lives. The presentation, by necessity, lacks a little fluidity as Ms Tedjarati changes from character to character, but the show leaves you with a greater understanding of the frustrations and determination of the protesters. And the plaintive message and melody of A Fire Ignites, This is Me will haunt you all day.

Malion, TheSpace at Surgeons’ Hall.

4-stars

I confess I’m not that au fait with the story of Pygmalion; he was a mythical sculptor who fell in love with a statue he had created – if you want to find out more, Ovid is your friend. In Tired Horses’ retelling of this myth, Piggy invites his scurrilous mates round to his studio to show off his new sculpture, his own vision of immaculate, pure beauty, of which he is enormously proud. The lads, however, are not so interested in depictions of classical beauty unless they can see her naked; when Piggy refuses, they tease him for not sharing their sexist and disrespectful view of women. They goad him into joining in with their appalling sexist behaviour. The statue, however, has other ideas… This is a powerful portrayal of misogyny and toxic masculinity and how, if unchecked, it grows and corrupts those around it. There are several genuinely horrible moments – but they work so well together that you’re completely hooked as to what happens next. Brilliantly written, full of inventiveness, very well acted, and a horrifying dissection of what makes some men behave the way they do.

The Last Laugh, Assembly George Square Studios.

4-stars

They used to say everyone knew where they were when JFK was shot. A generation later, everyone remembered where they were when Tommy Cooper died. I was at home, watching Live from Her Majesty’s on TV, looking forward to seeing the great man do his stuff and make me roar with laughter as he always had, ever since I was a little kid. A piece of all of us died that day. Paul Hendy’s The Last Laugh takes Cooper, together with those other long lost comic heroes, Eric Morecambe and Bob Monkhouse, and places them in an imaginary shared dressing room, getting ready to go on stage. They examine what motivates themselves as comedians, what it is that makes them laugh, what they get out of it, and who were their own comic heroes. Names like Robb Wilton, Arthur Askey and Max Miller are deeply rooted in the past now, but you never forget those who made you laugh in your formative years. Sheffield Panto’s very own Damian Williams is a perfect Tommy Cooper, dressed in vest, pants and fez, cutting a scruffy yet lovable figure. Northampton Panto’s very own Bob Golding is Eric Morecambe, enacting an excellent recreation of Morecambe’s physical humour and his rattle-gun laugh. Simon Cartwright brings back to the Fringe his extraordinarily accurate impression of Bob Monkhouse, the carefully mannered comic genius whose strength – and interest – in comedy rested more with the writing of jokes than in their performance. It’s a little over an hour of pure nostalgia, written from the heart and with some wry dramatic irony as we know how and when these heroes are going to leave us; but they don’t. Perhaps Monkhouse’s jealousy of Cooper’s and Morecambe’s natural ability to make us laugh is repeated a little too often; and the lighting/electricity crackling effect, which tells us that this is an imaginary event, is also overplayed. But it’s both a fascinating exploration of what makes comedy work, and a delightful stroll down comedy’s Memory Lane, tinged with just a bit of sadness. Great work by everyone!

A Jaffa Cake Musical, Pleasance Courtyard.

4-stars

Whilst everyone has their own opinion of this most pressing question – is a Jaffa Cake a cake or a biscuit? – you might not know that there was indeed a court case to determine the issue back in the 1990s when Customs and Excise wanted it proved that a Jaffa Cake is a biscuit so that it could attract Value Added Tax. And Gigglemug Theatre’s immensely entertaining A Jaffa Cake Musical takes us back to that legal wrangle and the barristers hired to argue the toss. Nicely delving into their legal training and family support for (or hilarious opposition to) their careers, we follow the tribunal’s daily progress until – finally – a decision is made! Written by Sam Cochrane, who plays defence barrister Kevin, and performed with great gusto and terrific musicality by a cast of five who belt out the witty songs to the accompaniment of Alex Prescot’s eloquent keyboard, you’ll lose yourself in the silly but fun story and catchy tunes. I did admire how the costumes inevitably included somewhere that delicious shade of orange that we all associate with the noble Jaffa Cake. You’ll be dying to eat one at the end!

Sooz Kempner: Class Of 2000, Underbelly Bristo Square.

3-stars

Sooz Kempner’s new show, the Class of 2000, takes us back to that very year when she took her GCSEs, when all it took to be chic was to drench yourself in Impulse. In this show, she’s trying to work out what Class actually is, and where she fits into its Big Picture. But she’s into dressage, so she must be posh, right? Sooz spends a little over an hour searching for Class in all the wrong places, and, as you would expect, there’s many a hilarious comic observation to laugh at and enjoy. She also takes the opportunity to deliver some of her outstanding singing impressions. Somehow, somewhere during the show, the comic narrative gets a little lost and some of her comic ideas don’t quite gel. A meetup with one of her TV heroines at the end also doesn’t quite flow organically. But it’s worth the ticket price to discover the value of horse jizz, let alone the rest of the show!

To Watch a Man Eat, Greenside at George Street.

3-stars

Behind every successful man there’s a good woman, they used to say in the rather patronising good old days. Meet Andrew: swiftly ascending the promotion ladder at his City financial services office – you know, the one founded by Daddy. And here’s his charming wife Melissa, always at hand to give him the boost and, erm, relief he needs. But which of them is the more ambitious? And what happens if somehow the greasy pole of success gets more slippery than either of them expected? Their fractious relationship is set alongside the life of happy-go-lucky firefighter Micky. Totally unstressed, despite the pitfalls of his work; luxuriating with a morning Tesco trifle for breakfast, making the best of his three-day weekends. He’s probably not going to get any higher up the promotion chain; but who’s got it right? Sadie Pearson’s witty and more than slightly terrifying new play explores some of the worst aspects of our personalities, and doesn’t shy away from some unappealing conclusions. The structure of the play occasionally feels a little over-complicated, and it takes a while for our understanding of the characters to fall into place, but it’s entertainingly acted by the cast of three – Lily Walker, George Usher and George Lorimer, whose slobbering over his spare rib dinner will be a memory hard to erase for a few days!

Colin Hoult: Colin, Pleasance Courtyard.

4-stars

The devilishly funny Colin Hoult has cast off the mantle of his wonderful creation Anna Mann and is now concentrating – arrogantly, he says – on himself with his show Colin. It’s very much a nostalgia-fest of his family life in Nottingham, with his weird uncles, aunts and brothers and his burping, farting father. Who plays with a Ouija board with a seven-year-old anyway? Encompassing his diagnosis of ADHD (other neurodiversities are available), it’s a very funny hour with a comedian who constantly riffs off the audience – so if you sit anywhere near the front, you will become involved! A very safe pair of comedic hands, and guaranteed laughter throughout.

The Shadow Boxer, TheSpace at Niddry Street.

4-stars

Jack is a bricklayer by day and a boxer by night. After an unexpected surprise win in his home town of Portsmouth, Jack sets his sights on representing Great Britain at the 1968 Olympics. With his beautiful fiancée Susan, they appear to live the perfect life – what could possibly go wrong? That’s one interpretation of this multi-levelled play; however, maybe none of this happened. Maybe it was all the fantasy of a troubled young man’s brain? It’s up to us the audience to decide for ourselves where the boundary between reality and delusion lies. Lucas English gives an excellent performance as Jack – or is it Isaac? – conveying the character’s desire to live an unrealistically model successful life mixed with his struggle to control rage. Or is his behaviour simply controlled by therapy? The clues are there: a late night brain teaser of a play!

The Edinburgh Fringe All Month Long – 5th August 2024

What’s on the slab for today? Seven shows – a busy day!

Here’s the schedule for August 5th

9:20 – A Fire Ignites, TheSpace @ Surgeons Hall.  From the Edinburgh Fringe website:

“A Fire Ignites tells the story of a brave teenage girl, Parisa, in modern-day Iran who sets her hijab on fire in public. Attacked by the morality police for her rebellion, she desires nothing more than to free her country from oppression. Her best friend, who shelters her, is exhausted from fighting and lives in fear. She and Parisa are opposites, as Parisa still believes that human beings are good despite all she has endured. Parisa’s mother fears for her daughter’s life, and conflict emerges. This story is inspired by the brave young women in Iran today.”

A serious play to start the day. One hears about the extraordinary protests in Iran from women who set fire to their hijab and the penalties they face, and one can only imagine how terrifying it must be and how brave they are. I’m hoping this will be a powerful and moving play and performance.

11:35 – Malion, TheSpace @ Surgeons Hall.

“A feminist retelling of the Pygmalion and Galatea myth. Malion, a sculptor, is presenting his work to his male friends, a statue of the most beautiful woman in creation. He rejoices in his achievement over drinks with some male friends. However, the conversation cannot move away from sexual fantasy and lust for the statue. Meanwhile, brought to life by Aphrodite’s kiss, Galatea awakens. Galatea seeks the love of her creator but he is changing, falling in line with his comrades and forgetting his pure vision of love. Will Malion see Galatea, or fall into the ranks of masculine identity?”

Perhaps a slightly unusual choice of play, but my curiosity was piqued by its premise! Athens meets Edinburgh – but who wins? Have very little idea of what to expect, but I hope it’s good!

13:20 – The Last Laugh, Assembly George Square Studios.

“The Last Laugh sees three legendary comedians – Tommy Cooper, Eric Morecambe and Bob Monkhouse – sitting in a dressing room, discussing the secret of life, death, comedy and what it means to be funny. Written and directed by the award-winning Paul Hendy and starring Edinburgh Fringe-legend Bob Golding as Morecambe, Damian Williams as Cooper and Simon Cartwright as Monkhouse, The Last Laugh is warm, funny, nostalgic and poignant. Not to be missed.”

I’m a great admirer of these three comic actors; we’ve seen Simon Cartwright’s impersonation of Bob Monkhouse before and it is truly uncanny, whereas Bob Golding is a mainstay of the pantos at the Royal and Derngate, Northampton, and there wouldn’t be a Sheffield panto without the master Dame, Damian Williams! I think this is going to turn out to be a big Fringe Highlight!

15:10 – A Jaffa Cake Musical, Pleasance Courtyard.

“Time to decide once and for all… cake or biscuit? Inspired by the 1991 tribunal which determined the true identity of a Jaffa Cake, multi-award winning Gigglemug Theatre (Scouts! The Musical, RuneSical, Timpson: The Musical) present a brand-new family-friendly musical comedy that takes the biscuit (or cake…?). Praise for previous productions: ‘Incredible!’ (Bear Grylls); ‘Laugh-a-minute silliness’ (Daily Express); ‘Winning songs’ (Guardian); ‘Blistering wit’ ***** (TheatreWeekly.com); ‘Simply brilliant’ ***** (NorthWestEnd.co.uk); ‘An utter masterpiece’ ***** (BoxOfficeRadio.co.uk); ‘A comedic triumph’ ***** (WestEndEvenings.co.uk); ‘Absolute bangers’ **** (Stage); ‘Genius’ **** (BroadwayBaby.com).”

Many years ago I used to work for Her Majesty’s Customs and Excise and I remember the constant arguments about whether a Jaffa Cake was a cake (food for VAT purposes) or a biscuit (confectionary) and they could never define it precisely enough so as to definitely apply the tax or have it zero-rated! For that reason alone I was fascinated by the idea of this show – and I do hope there will be some samples so that the audience can help decide whether it is… or isn’t!

18:20 – To Watch a Man Eat, Greenside @ George Street.

“Firefighter Micky and investment banker Andrew are choked by their respective blue and white collars. Micky puts the ‘man’ in manual, content with trifle for breakfast and all things analogue. He’s perplexed by people like Andrew, permanently in competition to keep his bum on his desk chair the longest, all in pursuit of the lifestyle his partner Melissa thirsts for. A wolf in a frilly apron, she lives to serve Andrew dinner and watch him tear it apart. In a world where ambition and personal values continuously butt heads, who will let themselves starve?”

This play is produced by the same team behind last year’s show Pressure Cooker which I really enjoyed, and that alone convinced me that it was worth giving this play a try! The class war examined at the dining table? Sounds excellent!

20:20 – Colin Hoult: Colin, Pleasance Courtyard.

“The acclaimed comedian and 2022 Edinburgh Comedy Award nominee returns with a stand-up show about family, fatherhood, and a formative childhood experience with a Ouija board and a gorilla. As seen in Afterlife (Netflix), Avoidance (BBC), Ghosts (BBC), This Time With Alan Partridge (BBC), and judging the 2023 BBC New Comedy Awards. ‘Terrific… you will laugh yourself silly throughout’ ***** (Telegraph). ‘Genius… one of the funniest comedy shows I’ve seen’ ***** (Times). ‘Superb’ ***** (TheArtsDesk.com). ‘Hilarious’ **** (Scotsman). **** (Independent). **** (Guardian). **** (Evening Standard).”

I was so sad last year when Colin Hoult finally killed off his hilarious comedy alter ego Anna Mann; but Mr H is such a funny guy that I know he’s going to have something equally hysterical up his sleeve for his new show all about himself. Early last year we saw a Work in Progress session with Mr H which I expect he has now developed up into this show – and I, for one, can’t wait to see it.

22:20 – The Shadow Boxer, TheSpace @ Niddy St.

“Portsmouth’s most promising featherweight boxer races towards his ultimate goal – competing in the 1968 Olympic Games and proving himself as a true champion. But can anyone control how their story will be told in an uncertain future?”

I don’t know why, but boxing frequently crops up in Fringe plays and it’s always a fascinating subject to include in theatre. Maybe it’s the balance between essentially physical violence but it has to be played within a framework of gentlemanly rules. I’ll be fascinated to see where this play fits in the scheme of boxing dramas.

Check back later to see how we enjoyed all these shows!