Edinburgh Fringe 2024 Reviews – i am george massey, Sherlock Holmes: The Last Act, Nettles, Hardly Working, and Nick Schuller: Still Dry White

i am george massey, TheSpace on The Mile.

Out of Context Theatre’s i am george massey provides a terrifying insight into how easy it is for someone to fall into the rabbit hole of depression and radicalisation. Childhood trauma results in his never fully coming to terms with who he is; he takes the counselling that is available but the degree to which it helps him is questionable. Suffering bad side effects of Citalopram, he posts a cry for help on the Internet, and it is Stan who answers and gives him support. But the Stans of this world can have ulterior motives. Raising very pertinent issues that affect us all, this is an emotional, gripping and powerful play; technically flawless, and immaculately written and performed by Stephen Dee.

Sherlock Holmes: The Last Act, Assembly Rooms.

4-stars

Nigel Miles-Thomas leads us through Sherlock Holmes’ greatest cases, his friendship with Watson, his enmity with Moriarty and his final days of retirement. But there’s also a fascinating glimpse into Holmes the Man, with a moving portrayal of his childhood days; the cruelty of his father and suffering of his mother. Mr Miles-Thomas takes on dozens of characterisations through this absorbing piece with a wonderful range of voices and accents, and I was hooked on his every word. It also made we want to go back and re-read all the Sherlock Holmes stories for myself. Truly engrossing!

Nettles, Greenside at George Street.

Alyona takes us through a history of her past sexual encounters, prompted by the possessions in an unknown man’s suitcase. It’s a patchwork of tales, loosely linked; and her memories suggest that all these encounters haven’t really made her at all happy. Jacqueline Lipman gives an intense performance but the show lacks substance, light and shade; and I confess I couldn’t quite put my finger on quite what it intended to achieve.

 

Hardly Working, TheSpace on The Mile.

Charity wanders into the bar where Lois works in order to hand in her CV – but she’s left it behind. Nevertheless, she gets a job and they strike up a relationship – with Charity making all the running. Lois moves in with Charity in Charity’s parents’ seven bedroomed house. This is wealth beyond Lois’ imagination. But she is uncomfortable at having everything bought for her – so starts to go flat-hunting without Charity’s knowledge. She’ll be happy at that, right? The powerplay between the two characters makes for an interesting subject, and the conclusion it draws is that the rich partner is only in it for the power and domination over the poor partner. Nothing really to do with class, as the blurb suggests, just money. Sadly, however, it’s very poorly presented, including an agonisingly slow process with a small whiteboard that the poor actor who plays Lois constantly has to rub out throughout the play, replacing Now with Then and back again, ad infinitum. That needs to be replaced with something that changes more quickly (a simple lighting change could perhaps suffice?) There’s a totally superfluous male character whose relevance never becomes apparent. There’s also some disappointing stagecraft – items that fell off the bar counter in one scene stayed on the floor for the rest of the play, whether or not it was now or then. Hopefully it can be tightened up during its run.

Nick Schuller: Still Dry White, Laughing Horse at the Eastside.

4-stars

Still Dry White is the perfect name for Nick Schuller’s show, as he’s extremely dry, does stay quite still during his performance, and – well you can guess the rest. He has a fantastic delivery style, very unhurried, careful and measured, with perfectly chosen words; the result is that the sting in the tail of many of his jokes comes totally unexpectedly and twice as funny. Not afraid of a pause in delivery – always the sign of a confident comedian – Mr Schuller has some brilliant material that frequently goes close to where angels fear to tread, but always stays on the funny side. An extremely enjoyable and surprisingly piquant hour of comedy.

The Edinburgh Fringe All Month Long – 12th August 2024

What’s in store for us in Edinburgh today?

Here’s the schedule for August 12th.

10:20 – i am george massey,   theSpace on the Mile. From the Edinburgh Fringe website:

“What does it mean to be English anymore?… Strawberries? Scones? Jerusalem?… What is England now? This is George’s story: powerful, shocking, radical. a story of childhood joy, passionate relationships, and how he slowly falls down the dark rabbit hole of radicalisation. Manchester born and bred, George tries to manage his loneliness and depression through his phone. A lifeboat that helps him to not feel alone. Social media can bring you to the surface, or it can take you deeper into the depths. An immersive monologue that treads the boundaries of dark comedy and tragedy.”

The rise of radicalisation, through subversive social media, is a fascinating subject and I hope that this meaty-looking play tackles the subject head on. I’m expecting this to be a very hard-hitting watch.

14:25 –  Sherlock Holmes: The Last Act, Assembly Rooms.

“Revealing the man behind the myth… exposing the great detective’s fears and weaknesses, the devastating consequences of the dramas of his formative years, and unexpectedly, his cutting sense of humour. It is 1916. Drawn from two years of Sussex retirement for the funeral of his friend, Dr Watson, Holmes returns to Baker Street to resolve The Last Act. A theatrical evening then unfolds, with 14 characters, all played by Nigel Miles-Thomas. Features cross-examinations and heated arguments between Holmes and Watson. Written by Conan Doyle expert David Stuart Davies and directed by award-winning Gareth Armstrong.”

Time for a spot of dignified, traditional theatre in the company of Nigel Miles-Thomas, and the character of Sherlock Holmes, who continues to intrigue and delight us more than a century after Conan Doyle wrote his famous exploits. I think this will be smart, satisfying and tremendously well done.

16:15 – Nettles, Greenside @ George Street.

“Alyona is in her mid-twenties and has no place to settle down. She is invited to stay at Giovanni’s Sloane Square house for a night… without his knowledge. Intrigued and excited by this rich man’s world, Alyona searches through his possessions, with some of his belongings bringing flashbacks of past experiences. Now, feeling vulnerable, Alyona lets you into parts of her identity, sexuality, and daydreaming fantasy world.”

This sounds like another hard-hitting play that should expose the reality of the vulnerability of young people in desperation. Hopefully it will be well-written and acted.

18:05 – Hardly Working, theSpace on the Mile.

“Trust, truth, and tequila. Could you date someone of the opposite class? Does class actually determine politics? What happens when the patriarchy walks into a bar? Hang on, this was meant to be funny… After a preview showcase at Bristol Old Vic in June, this new play by Jessie Millson follows a queer relationship blasted apart by politics and pranks. We are placed between worker and slacker, between filthy rich and stinking poor, between staying or going as the bar between Charity and Lois becomes a bigger and bigger boundary. Do you serve to live or live to serve?”

This play poses some interesting questions! Britain is still riddled with class issues, and they’re not going away soon. I’ve really enjoyed Jessie Millson’s writing in the past and hope this will be equally as entertaining!

20:00 – Nick Schuller: Still Dry White, Laughing Horse @ Eastside.

“Dry (adjective) – a subtle, ironic or matter-of-fact joke or sense of humour. If you like dry humour, see Nick Schuller at the Edinburgh Fringe. Dry (adjective) – an alcoholic beverage that is not sweet. Depending on how the show goes, Nick may drink a lot of still dry white.”

Nick Schuller arrives in Edinburgh from Australia, where he has been making quite a name for himself in comedy festivals. I’ve seen a couple of videos of his work and I’m expecting this to be extremely funny!

Check back later to see how we enjoyed all these shows!