Edinburgh Fringe 2024 Reviews – Josh Makinda is Probably Fine, The Ghost of White Hart Lane, Mark Row: A* in the Making – Revision Lesson, Kelly Bachman: Patron Saint, and Thank You So Much For Coming

Josh Makinda is Probably Fine, Just the Tonic at the Mash House.

3-stars

Only seven people turned up to see Josh Makinda is Probably Fine at Just The Tonic at The Mash House; nevertheless Mr M gave us a very entertaining show, albeit probably a little different from the act he normally delivers. He’s a very funny guy indeed, with a delightful ear for the mischievous and the surreal, constantly wandering up comical garden paths to explore whatever comedy nuggets might be hiding. His material includes the pitfalls of his previous job protecting vulnerable children, exploring his venue for glory holes, and his experience of US healthcare. He sets up an excellent connection with the audience and cuts a warm and appealing persona on stage. He fully deserves a much larger audience – sometimes at the Fringe it’s worth taking a risk on someone you’ve never heard of – you might just strike gold.

The Ghost of White Hart Lane, Underbelly Bristo Square.

4-stars

John White was born in Musselburgh in 1937 and died aged 27 in 1964 from a lightning strike; a freak accident – he was sheltering under a tree from a thunderstorm at the time. He was also an international football player for Scotland, and a player for Alloa Athletic, Falkirk, and most significantly, Tottenham Hotspur. Martin Murphy’s tightly written and nimbly structured play calls for a powerful and versatile performance from Cal Newman. He plays John White, both in the early days of his career and at the time of his death, and John’s son Rob White, as a brave eight-year-old fondly keeping souvenirs of his father in a trunk, and as a mature adult with a family of his own. The play jumps around the time periods somewhat, but Newman’s performance always nails the characterisations and accents perfectly. Though sad, the play is never maudlin, and is a fitting tribute to a sporting hero cut down in his prime, and the son who wants to celebrate and cherish his memory.

Mark Row: A* in the Making – Revision Lesson, Laughing Horse at the Hanover Tap.

3-stars

Mark Row dishes out the background stories and classroom anecdotes that make up life as a schoolteacher. His subject is Drama, which, as we all know, is merely about pretending to be a tree; but Mr Row has an alternative method of looking at that particular cliché. He is an imposing yet friendly figure on stage – in fact, you can exactly imagine what he would be like as a schoolteacher; the authoritative voice, the ability to control a group of people (not in a bad way), and the truly positive wish for his schoolkids to develop into the best people they can possibly be. It’s a very enjoyable and entertaining hour; perhaps I expected his material to be a little edgier and push the boundaries a bit more. I did, however, learn about the code teachers use when they’re writing reports, when they can’t be as truthful as they would like to be – you’ll be rooting out all your old reports to decode them and discover exactly what your teachers thought of you! Engaging, funny, likeable, and very recognisable.

Kelly Bachman: Patron Saint, Assembly Rooms.

4-stars

Now and again a show comes along that stops you in your tracks because its content is so personal and so painful; but it’s the kind of content that just needs to be told. When someone is the victim of so terrible a crime as rape, it’s not for anyone else to tell that person how they should deal with it. Kelly Bachman has turned her own experiences into Patron Saint, a show that puts rape centre stage, looks at it straight in the eyes, gives it no hiding place, and makes it the butt of its own joke. Her ability to turn this awful crime on its head is not only a way of coping with it, but also of ridiculing it, even demystifying it. Ms Bachman has a superb comic timing and a terrific ability to mine comedy from what one would normally think of as – at the very least – an extremely unfunny subject. I can only suggest you see it yourself and draw your own conclusions.

Thank You So Much For Coming, Underbelly Cowgate.

3-stars

Cynthia is known for her great parties, and we are invited! It all starts promisingly as we are offered hors d’oeuvres (not that After Eights are really hors d’oeuvres, but that doesn’t matter) and guests find out about each other, and Cynthia even helps a couple of people swap phone numbers. Margaritas are served – although they’re represented by a couple of Barbie Dolls – a member of the audience answers the phone, and it looks like some of the guests are not going to turn up. Donatella Versace is a no-show; Bernie Sanders also disappoints. And then things start getting very messy, apeshit surrealist and 100% bizarre. A good reason for choosing shows at the Fringe is that you’re unlikely to see anything like it anywhere else – and I can confirm you are absolutely not likely to see anything like Thank You So Much For Coming anywhere else. Alex Kern plays Cynthia with true clowning panache; there are elements of absurd theatre, Beckett, even Dada. If you hate this kind of performance, you’d give it one star; if you love this kind of performance it’s a five star. My reaction is in the middle.

The Edinburgh Fringe All Month Long – 22nd August 2024

More adventure awaits us, let’s have a look.

Here’s the schedule for August 22nd.

12:00 – Josh Makinda Is Probably Fine, Just the Tonic at The Mash House. From the Edinburgh Fringe website:

“Josh Makinda is bringing his debut solo show to the Edinburgh Fringe! Australian, Kenyan-ethnicity, but NYC-based, Josh has been wowing audiences the world over with his unique brand of sharp wit, whip-smart ad-libs and colossal tales of life, wonder and unwellness. You are next! Come and laugh until your tummy hurts; his already does (IBS)! ‘…Josh Makinda had the audience in his palm… I laughed for a solid fifty minutes, you probably will too.’ (IsolatedNation.com). ‘Josh Makinda is a rarity… it’s comedy of the first order’ (The West Australian).”

We start the day with some comedy from a land down under. I’ve not heard of Josh Makinda before but he arrives with lots of complimentary notices, so I have good hopes of some comedy gold.

13:25 – The Ghost of White Hart Lane, Underbelly, Bristo Square.

“Spurs and Scotland star John White was one of the best footballers of the 1960s, however, in July 1964 he was struck by lightning and killed at 27 years old. From humble beginnings growing up just outside Edinburgh, through to football fame and his tragic death, the play shares John’s cheeky humour. It also follows the story of his son Rob White, who was just five months old when his dad died. Having premiered at Spurs Stadium, this follows on from the Sunday Times bestseller by Rob White and Julie Welch.”

I have never heard about the story of John White, but hopefully this play will provide a good insight into his achievements and be a fitting honour.

18:15 – Mark Row: A* in the Making – Revision Lesson, Laughing Horse @ The Hanover Tap.

“After 18 years as a teacher, Mark Row has had enough of the endless carousel of uninspiring lessons, inane questions and kids with attitudes that stink worse than their PE kits. So now he’s seeking a new life on stage, but will the glamorous world of stand-up comedy really prove to be much better? Mark Row returns to Edinburgh with tales from the classroom for anyone who has ever been a teacher, been to school, or who just likes laughing at children. An outstanding lesson in how entertain!”

On a number of times over the past few years we have so nearly seen Mark Row perform, but for some reason he has always missed out in the final reel. No excuses this time, so I hope he lives up to his reputation!

19:45 – Kelly Bachman: Patron Saint, Assembly Rooms.

“Patron Saint is an hour of stand-up about spirituality, sexuality, virality and why anyone is funny. More specifically, it’s an hour of stand-up by Kelly Bachman, a comedian and rape survivor who found herself with sudden notoriety after encountering serial predator Harvey Weinstein at a comedy show in New York. Kelly was then asked to talk to CNN, The Guardian and a documentary called Hysterical on FX/Hulu, too. Years later, Kelly still hears one recurring question: ‘Are you a comedian because of trauma?’ Patron Saint aims to answer that question.”

This subject matter for this comedy hour couldn’t be more relevant and contemporary. I haven’t come across Ms Bachman before but with any luck this should be hard-hitting top quality comedy.

22:15 – Thank You So Much for Coming, Underbelly, Cowgate.

“You are cordially invited… Cynthia, the ultimate party host, is in the midst of throwing her most fabulous party ever! A hilarious, immersive one-woman character clown show that explores loneliness, femininity, and the pressure to be seen. Playful, absurd and unhinged, Cynthia wrestles with desire and disgust at the prospect of being loved and known in a world filled with ubiquitous, yet too often empty, encounters. A delightful descent into pure madness! Awards: Best Immersive (TVO Awards), Best of Broadwater (Hollywood Fringe). ‘A beautifully surreal show with an extraordinary performance’ (Noho Arts).”

I’m up for helping Cynthia enjoy her fabulous late night party, although I have a feeling she might unravel before our eyes. I’m hoping it’s not too surreal because that might get a little tiresome. Fingers crossed it’s pitched perfectly!

Check back later to see how we enjoyed all these shows!