Edinburgh Fringe 2024 Reviews – Ambiguous Proposition, An Act of Grace, It’s a Mystery, The Imitator, Richard Cobb: Running Joke, and Garry Starr: Classic Penguins

Ambiguous Proposition, TheSpace at Surgeons’ Hall.

3-stars

Margaret is a well-established employment tribunal judge. She loves her job and she’s heard it all; she knows the tricks of the trade, the delaying tactics, the games that lawyers play. Bradley, her son, finally gets a job – not the best, but it’s a start; and he seems to be getting on well with one of his colleagues, Chloe. But when Chloe alleges sexual harassment against him at work, this has a knock-on effect on Margaret’s position too; resulting in Margaret having the double battle to protect both her son and her own job. An intriguing and engrossing story that plays on our imagination, as we never actually meet Bradley or Chloe, so it’s impossible for the audience to conclude who is telling the truth. Smartly performed by Hilary Cordery; a deliberately inconclusive ending is a little frustrating but emphasises that the play is about the wider side effects of such allegations rather than the outcome of the case. I’m not sure the repeated use of the F word adds much to the play or helps our understanding of the character, and the assumptions of guilt in the story seem a little one-sided. But it firmly holds one’s attention and is a very meaty start to one’s Fringe day.

An Act of Grace, TheSpace at Niddry Street.

4-stars

A lawyer and a financial services adviser are invited to meet Grace at her grand apartment. The two men knew each other at school and are still knowledgeable about each other’s careers. Grace tells them that she is in need of their services; but then she has a double bombshell to drop – and no one’s life will be the same again! Ottawa Little Theatre bring john Muggleton’s An Act of Grace to the Edinburgh Fringe and it’s a playful, twisty-turny show about devious people who aren’t necessarily what they seem to be. A classic comedy thriller with no ulterior motive than to entertain and surprise its audience. Great fun, elegantly staged, and very well acted.

It’s a Mystery, TheSpace at Surgeons’ Hall.

4-stars

Tim Benzie delivers an interactive and lively comedy lecture on the art of writing and appreciating a good whodunit, taking Agatha Christie as his template classic detective fiction writer, but bringing many other authors and works into the equation. He also has a murder mystery of his own for us to solve, and there’s a helpful dollop of Cluedo in there as well. Light-hearted, constantly surprising, but also full of fascinating facts and recommendations, Mr B also draws conclusions as to why he is so personally attracted to the genre. A terrific entertainment if you’re a whodunit buff, and, let’s face it, who isn’t? Highly recommended!

The Imitator, Assembly Rooms.

3-stars

Julian Fontalvo takes to the stage to tell the story of his life and how he got to where he is today, from Colombia via New York and Madrid to Edinburgh. He has an extraordinary gift of imitating famous singers – hence the name of his show – not only in their voice, but also in their mannerisms and performance styles; and The Imitator showcases this gift through a selection of dozens of songs and singers, linked by his own narrative. Superb lighting and a strong sound system really helped give the music impact; and the crowd went wild.

Richard Cobb: Running Joke, Laughing Horse at the Raging Bull.

3-stars

Following on from his Couples’ Massage show, Richard Cobb is back from honeymoon, with all the trappings of marriage now that he and his wife have a dog, and full of his experience of running the Edinburgh Marathon. No stranger to fear, he’s skydived and lived to tell the tale, so the Marathon? Gotta be a cinch – he’d probably nail it in under four hours. Along the way he has some engaging stories about putting off the training until the time is right, and his unofficial rivalry with a blind runner dressed as a dog. Mr Cobb is most at home when recounting memories immersed in angst and guilt, and this show is crammed with such material; it even has the statutory 40-minute-in sad bit. Don’t expect a brash and showbizzy presentation, it’s more like listening to a well-trusted old mate letting you into his secrets. Subtle and wry, this is a finely structured hour of comedy, constantly entertaining and heartwarming.

Garry Starr: Classic Penguins, Pleasance Courtyard.

A Garry Starr show is never just a show. It’s a concept, it’s an event; it’s an exploration of absurdity and trust between performer and audience. In Classic Penguins, Garry takes a shelf full of Penguin paperbacks and acts out a scene that you might just possibly associate with each book title. Just two things to note: the connection between the title and what Mr Starr does (usually assisted by members of the audience) might be very loose indeed. And he’ll be wearing next to nothing; by the end of the hour, all he’s got on is his Elizabethan ruff – he is a thespian of the highest calibre, after all. Even if you’ve seen Garry Starr before, nothing can prepare you for the total batshit craziness of this show. To give you any more clues as to what takes place would be to diminish it for future audiences. No one has commitment to his clowning and physical comedy like Garry Starr. Fearless, frenetic and fabulous!

The Edinburgh Fringe All Month Long – 20th August 2024

It’s another busy day so let’s take a look.

Here’s the schedule for August 20th.

9:55 – Ambiguous Proposition, theSpace @ Surgeons’ Hall. From the Edinburgh Fringe website:

“A controversial sexual harassment allegation pushes Margaret to the edge of reason. How far can she go to protect her son? How far can she go to protect herself? How far can they bend the truth? Ambiguous Proposition explores the nature of harassment in the workplace through the lens of a mother of a son accused, ultimately questioning whether a man can survive an allegation of sexual harassment in the years post #MeToo. Created by two employment lawyers, this piece of provocative new writing delves into the searing reality of equality at work. Performed by Hilary Cordery.”

Another meaty play to start the day, and the whole area of sexual harrassment in the workplace is a nightmare, to the victim, the accused, the onlookers, and those responsible for dealing with it. Here we see it through the family of the accused, and I think this has the potential to be a very powerful piece.

12:05 – An Act of Grace, theSpace @ Niddry St.

“Grace, a wealthy and mysterious woman, invites an ex-golf pro turned financial advisor and a lawyer with sordid secrets to her country home to discuss her estate and update her will. What could go wrong? Everything… quickly. Once there, the two men are thrust into a game of survival that, if lost, will destroy their lives. From the Canadian producers that brought you the 2022 Carol Tambor Award-winning production of Burn, this contemporary thriller by the same playwright has enough twists and turns to keep audiences on the edge of their seats.”

I’m choosing to see this play purely on the strength of that description. It sounds very exciting! Let’s hope it is.

13:40 – It’s a Mystery! theSpace @ Surgeons’ Hall.

“Tim Benzie, the acclaimed creator and host of Solve Along A Murder She Wrote, returns to the Fringe with his hilarious and moving one-man show: a deep dive into the enduring appeal of whodunnits, from Poirot to Fletcher and beyond. The audience are summoned to the drawing room as Detective Tim examines the clues that first drew him to the genre. Take a journey from Cluedo to Christie to solve the mystery of why everyone is a little bit Columbo (or should be). ‘A killer of a show’ ***** (WestEndBestFriend.co.uk).”

Doesn’t everyone love a whodunnit? I certainly do, with my book favourites being Christie, P D James and – way back in my past – Ngaio Marsh who now seems very out of favour. I’m expecting this to be a very endearing and possibly nostalgic look at the genre.

16:00 – The Imitator, Assembly Rooms.

“Winner: Best International Show, United Solo Festival, New York. Music and songs are the key elements that trigger Julian’s memories, and set him off on a journey back to his childhood in South America where he discovers his passion for music and his gift for imitating voices. From there, he faces struggles in New York and Europe as he pursues his dream of becoming an artist. Singer/actor Julian Fontalvo portrays different characters that play a part in his story and imitates 70 artists such as Sting, Bob Marley, David Bowie, Amy Winehouse and Tina Turner.”

A cross between a play and a performance vehicle for a musical impersonator? I’ve no idea, but I’m looking forward to finding out.

18:30 – Richard Cobb: Running Joke, Laughing Horse @ The Raging Bull.

“Following a host of sell-out shows and hot on the heels of last year’s debut, Couple’s Massage, Scottish comedian and writer Richard Cobb returns to the track with a brand-new hour filled with more guilt-tripped and incredibly stressful anecdotes. The honeymoon is over and the running shoes are on. But can he really win the Edinburgh Marathon? ‘I’ve been going to the Fringe for 25 years or so and genuinely this is the most impressive full debut I’ve seen from a stand up’ (Audience review). ‘He has an easy affable charm’ (Lancaster Guardian).”

We saw Richard Cobb’s Couple’s Massage last year and I thought he showed great promise, so I’m looking forward to seeing what he has up his sleeves for us this year. If the show is about him entering the Edinburgh Marathon then it’s the perfect title!

20:30 – Garry Starr: Classic Penguins, Pleasance Courtyard.

“Literature! Literature! It might not rhyme with anything but it’s still very important. Garry Starr is back and he’s hell-bent on saving books from extinction by performing every Penguin Classic novel ever written. In an hour. Mostly naked (but with flippers). Comic wunderkind Starr takes us on a literary adventure through the world’s most iconic works of fiction. From The Little Prince to Moby Dick and everything in between, nothing is safe from being lampooned with the utmost nincompoopery. Directed by Cal McCrystal and Georgia Murphy. ‘From clownish chaos to feats of comic genius’ **** (Guardian).”

One of the things I will always be grateful to the Edinburgh Fringe for is discovering the manic hilarity of Garry Starr. He never fails to have us in hysterics, and I’m sure this year will be no different.

Check back later to see how we enjoyed all these shows!